If you are looking for a wedding dessert other than the traditional wedding cake, or you are looking for wedding dessert ideas to go along with your wedding cake or you just want some nice sweet treats to serve at your bridal shower, bachelorette party or other pre-wedding event then you will want to check out these 14 wedding dessert ideas that aren’t cake.
A host of other sweet goodies are joining wedding cakes on the wedding dessert table. From brownies and candy bars to pies and sundaes, donuts and ice cream to s’mores and chocolate sundaes, wedding desserts other than wedding cake are increasingly being served.
Whether you’re a nonconformist or just want to supplement your dessert with other yummy treats, these delicious options will stand out from the wedding cake crowd. From finger foods to mini versions of the classics, here are 15 dessert alternatives sure to satisfy everyone’s sweet tooth.
1. Waffle Sundaes
Breakfast food is an all-around crowd-pleaser that can be served at any time—especially when it’s a la mode. Offering different ice cream flavors and toppings like berries, sprinkles and hot fudge will appeal to every guest’s taste buds.
2. Mini Pies on a Stick
Anything you can eat on a stick is an idea we can totally get behind. Pies of all different flavors, like apple, blueberry, chocolate or banana cream, will guarantee there’s something for everyone at your wedding, and their fun-size portions allow your guests to try more than one flavor.
3. Berry Parfaits
Fruit and yogurt parfaits are a great go-to dessert for a healthy (and gluten-free!) option. Guests can create their own parfait and add ingredients from a fruit and yogurt bar, or if you’d like to encourage more mixing and mingling during the reception, have attendants pass them around to keep the energy and movement levels up.
4. Cake Push Pops
Cake push pops are easy to eat (aka guests can eat with one hand while they’re getting down on the dance floor), they look super-cute on display and they take the idea of a cake pop to the next level. Color coordinate the frosting in the push pop as a nod to your wedding color palette.
Glazed, frosted or plain old cake, everyone loves a good doughnut. Reach out to a local bakeshop to try and get the freshest, yummiest treats for your reception. Display them on tiers to mimic a multitiered cake, or go for something a little different, like a doughnut wall or mounds of little doughnut holes.
6. Pudding Parfaits
Meet the grown-up version of everyone’s favorite childhood treat: chocolate pudding, Oreo crumbles and gummy worms, aka the dirt cup. The modern, sleek parfait glass makes for a fancy display, while the green garnish acts as a sophisticated upgrade from gummy worms. Just set out utensils and you’re good to go!
7. Milk and Cookies
Who doesn’t love a good batch of homemade cookies with a glass of milk? Give your guests a true nighttime snack experience by saving these treats until later in the evening, when friends and family need a little pick-me-up. Offer up tried-and-true favorites, like chocolate chip, butterscotch, snickerdoodle and peanut butter.
The classic graham cracker, marshmallow and chocolate sandwich is bound to be a hit. Take this campfire favorite to the next level by serving it up with unexpected add-ins, like candied bacon, cookie butter and salted caramels. (Pro tip: Put out a basket of a wet wipes so guests can easily clean up sticky fingers without having to wait in line for the bathroom.)
9. Rice Krispies Treat Cake
Opting for lighter fare but still want something that resembles a cake? A Rice Krispies treat cake is airy and delicious and can be molded to any shape, including (but not limited to!) the traditional tier.
10. Dippin’ Dots
The ice cream of the future is a great mess-free alternative to its scoopable counterpart. They’re fun to eat, easy to serve and come in a variety of mouthwatering flavors.
11. Whoopie Pies
This traditional dessert from Maine is a great option. The cakey sandwich filled with frosting is a less formal, finger-food version of a conventional cake. Ask around to see if you can find a baker who offers fun flavors—that usually comes hand-in-hand with playful color palettes and artful displays.
12. Bundt Cakes
Bundt cakes are another great dessert selection because you still get a tasty cake consistency at a very affordable price (the lack of frosting and piping cut down on labor expenses). Place one on each table as a unique centerpiece (giving guests the freedom to cut into each one themselves), or display a few different flavors on a dessert table. Guests are still able to enjoy a spongy cake dessert and you don’t have to go over budget on a decadent cake.
13. Cake Pops
If you’re looking to serve up something a little more modern but still want to bring in a kind of cake to your reception, go for a tiered cake pop cake. You can color coordinate the pops with your color scheme or create a mild ombre effect—and don’t forget the topper!
14. Homemade Pop Tarts
Ever since Ted’s Bulletin reintroduced America to the classic pop tart (just check out their Instagram!), they’ve been a coveted confection. Give your guests a bite of childhood nostalgia with classic pop tart flavors like blueberry or strawberry, or go for something a little more creative like cookies and cream.